  
  


  ,        .    - .          .                 -,      .              .        .   ,          ,      .           .





 

  


   



   10010098           



:

  ,             . . 



  . ., 2012

 .     , 2012







            , , , .      ,            .

,                . ,        .    , , ,   .          .          ,  , , , , , , ,          ().           .             .             .

               ,    .        ,    .     , ,  .       .   ,      ,        .     .         .    ,          -    .

        : , , , ,   .         ,       .

     ,   .          ,          .              ,    ;            ,  ,         ,    .  ,              .  ,         ,      ,              .

        ,         , ,    ,       .   ,          ,  ,    ,      .         .

    ,    . ,     ,    . , ,      .   ,    ,   .     ,    ,    ,     ,     ,   ,   ,    ,  - ,    黠          ,    .   ,     ,         ,    ,  .

           ,          ,     ,  92%   ,                   .      .

,  ,   .         .     ,     .      . ,   , , , ,[1 - .   :    . .: , 1986;    80- .   . .: , 1979;   . .: , 1972;    . .: , 1986. .  :  . .   . .: - , 1985;  . .,  . . 12  . .: , 1987; - . .  . .: - , 1985;  . .,  . .  . .: , 1982;  . .     . .: , 1975.] ,       - ,        .

,    1020        .      . .   . . ,          .[2 -  . .         . : -  . . -, 2003;  .  :    . .; : -  . . -, 2004;  . .   .     . .: - , 2002.]       .            :     ,     ,     ,  .     ,   ,   ,            .   ,                ,   

       ,      ,           ,      .[3 -        .]




 1

         





1.1

  


             .   -              ,          -    .               .  ,        ()    ,    ,   .      ,          -                 .      ,  : 1)         , 2)         3)     .[4 -       . ., .:  . .     . .: , 1998. . 1114; : , ,  (- ) / . . . . . .: , 2001. . 1133;  :  . .:  , 1997; Bradley J., Ewing M. Constitutional and Administrative Law. L., Harlow: Pearson Press, 2003. P. 153156; Durand C. Confdration de tats et tat federal. P.: Flammarion, 1995. P. 79. . : Hogg P. The Constitutional Law of Canada. Agincourt (Ont.): Carswell, 2007. P. 7274; Smiley D. The Federal Condition in Canada. Toronto: McGraw-Hill  Ryerson, 1991. P. 47.]      .

        ,             -  .     ,  ,       ,            ,    -  ,       , .         ,   . ,  ,  ,     ,       200  ,       (            ).     ,   ,   [5 -       1999.]       .         ,     -  ,              XX .[6 -  .: Federalism. The Multiethnic Challenge / ed. by G. Smith. L.; N. Y.: Longman, 1999. P. 2431; Phillips O. H. Constitutional and Administrative Law. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2008. P. 255.]

 ,                 ,    (XIV.).          -,         (. , . , . , . , . ),     -   (. , . , . . , .    ..).[7 - Barnett J. Constitutional and Administrative Law. L.: Macmillan, 2003. P. 187, 190, 201; Laselva S. The Moral Foundations of Canadian Federalism. Paradoxes, Achievments and Tragedies of the Nationhood. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1996. P. 193194.]       -,    . , . , . , . , .   ..,[8 -        : Friedrich C. Theory and Practice of Federalism. N. Y.: Praeger, 1968; King P. Federalism and Federations. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press, 1982.]        .

,     -   , ..    XVIII   XIX., ,            .              ,        .     XIX .   -    ,  ,       ,  - ,  .      -        ,   - ,         .             ,        .[9 -  .: Heard A. The Canadian Constitutional Conventions. Marriage of Law and Politics. Oxford; N. Y.: Oxford Univ. Press, 1991. . 3940; Marshall G. The Constitutional Conventions. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1986. . 79, 16; Oliver M. The Passionate Debates. Confederation or Federation? Montreal: Vehicule Press, 2001. P. 228239.]        ,   ,  ,  ,   ,           .      -     .

              XVIII.          , .         ,   .[10 - Whitaker R. Federalism and Democratic Theory. Essays in Principles and Their Implementation. 2nd ed. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 2000. P. 2531.]    , ,       ,      .                ,        (   , ,   ..[11 - .: Federalist Papers. Essays by Hamilton A., Madison J. and Jay J. /ed. by J. Brock. L.: Dent Publishers, 1997. P. 7274, 234236.]).  -       ,        ,   .      ,      ,  . , . , . , .    - , . , . , . .   .     ,         ,     ,    ,      ,     ..,     ,        .

      XVIIIXIX .            ,           .[12 -  .:    XVIIXVIII. .: , 1983.]

            ,     .      ,     ,   .         ()       ,      .        ,    ,    ,   ,       .   -          (  ,  )      (    ).          . .     -  O  ,[13 -  . .  . .: , 1955. . 268269. . : Banks M.-F. Understanding Canadian Constitution. L. (Ont.): Univ. of Western Ontario Press, 1991. . 1116; Reconciling the Solitudes. Essays on Canadian Federalism and Nationalism / ed. by G. Laforest, M. Trebilcock. Montreal; L.: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 2003. P. 457458.]    ,    .

             ,        .        -                ,     (   )   ,      ,       .

                      (  ),     ( XVIII.)          .          .  (17511836)[14 - The Federalist Papers P. 110157  .]  .  (17431826).    -         .   (18051859).[15 -  . .    . .:  , 2000; The Federalist Papers]      ,           , ,   .        ,    .[16 -  . . . . . 312, 315; Nation-State versus Continental Integration / ed. by L. Pal, R. Schultze. Bochum: Universitatsverlag, 1993. P. 176; Verney D. Three Civilizations, Two Cultures, One State. Canadian Political Traditions. Durham (N.C.): Duke Univ. Press, 1996. P. 372, 373.]           .[17 -     .: : , ,  . 5; Boothe P. et al. Alberta and Constitutional Change. Edmonton: Western Centre for Research, 1992; Durand C. Op. cit.]    ,      ,           ,          ,         .         -[18 - ., .:  . . . .:  -, 2004. . 291308.] (      ).

                   -              -      -,    - .       ,          ,    .

  ,    XVIII     XIX     ,                 ,       -     ,       -           .[19 - .: Martin G. et al. The Causes of the Confederation. Fredericton (N.B.): Acadian Press, 1990. . , 46. ,                       ,           ,    -  .  ,                         .]

    -    ,       ,          .          .      -  . , . , .    - . (       .)  ,         ,       .    ,          ,          :             (  , ,   ),[20 -     -  (,  .   .   ,   , .   .   )              .  ,  :         (sic!) ,      ,       .  :         ( .  .   . .: - . . -, 2005. . 154, 171).  ,               (. ).]        ,  , ,   ,    .

   ,    .  (17821850),                       ,                  ()       ()  .    ,     .   . ,    ()    .          ,        ,       .[21 - Calhoun J. A Discourse on the Constitution and Government. N. Y.: Lippincott Publishing House,1849. P. 118, 146. . : The Canadian and American Constitutions in Comparative Perspective / ed. by M. McKenna, R. Gibbins. Calgary: Univ. of Calgary Press, 1999. P. 72; Dufour C.  Canadian Challenge. Halifax: Institute for Research on Public Policy, 1990. P. 4041; Forbes H. et al. Atlantic Provinces in Confederation. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1994. . 129.]      ,     -        .    : 1)            2)            -    .

 ,  :        ,   ,    ,        .     ,     ,    ,    ,    (   . . .).[22 - Borel . tude sur la souverainete et lEtat federatif. P.: Flammarion, 1886. P. 103.]

                        ,             ,[23 - ., .: Broadway R. The Folly of Decentralization in Canadian Federation. Calgary: Detselig Publishers, 1996. P. 124127, 132.] -          .             ,                  .

           - -               . . , .-.   . . ,       .           -      .[24 - .:  .-. . .: , 1998.]

              ,     - .  (18591928).          ,   .    ,     (. . 1.2 . .),            ,               .  :      ,        ;    ,      ( ? . .)            (?)   .[25 -  . . . . 184.    ,      ,     ,                      (, )   .]

                  ,            .   -,    . ,             ,[26 - Dicey A. An Introduction to the Study of the Constitution. 10th ed. Indianapolis: Liberty Classics, 1982. P. 8586; . : Scott F. Essays on Constitution. Aspects of Canadian Law and Politics. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1987. P. 60.]          ,   .   , ,       ,           .             .        . ,   .   -  .[27 -         - (. . 1.2 . .).]  ,   ,      .   . ,      XX .,                  .[28 - Wheare K. The Federal Government. L.: Routlege and Keegan, 1964. P. 33.]

            XX .[29 - ,        (1983.)     .  .     (. 1, 1987.)      .]    -,    .  (18341901)         ,   ,     .        :    ,     .  ,    -    ?         ,  ,              .       ()    ( ),     .             ,        셻[30 - Acton J. Essays on Freedom and Power. Cleveland; Evanston: Univ. Press of America, 1962. P. 158159.]   .         .         ()    () .    ,       -    ,  ,           .[31 - Ibid. P. 170.       .]   ,     ,               .  ,        ,             .[32 - Federalism and Nationalism / ed. by M. Forsyth. L.; Leicester: Leicester Univ. Press, 1989. P. 118; Laselva S. Op. cit. P. 89.]

 ,         ,     ,    .      ,        .      ,  ,                 .  ,           ,         ,             .[33 - ., .: Storing G. The Complete Anti-Federalist. Chicago: Walsh Company, 1981. P. 60, 113.]

     - . .                ,    .                     .[34 -  .   . .: , 1929. . 545548, 567.]  ,       - (. , . , .   .)                    .       ,          .                 .            .

   ,     XIX. -   ,      ,      ,            ,           .          ,          . ,       XIX  XX   -             -  .[35 - .: Giguel G. Le droit constitutionnel et institutions administrative. P.: Larousse, 2007; Ormsby W. The Emergence of a Federal Concept in Canada. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1969.]       .[36 - ., .:  . .    (   ). .: , 2006. . 5253.]

   -        ,        ,         ,   ,      .    ,         ,      - .   ,    ,       (. , . )       ,    ,   .




1.2

     (. , . , . , . )


       ,      ,              .      XX               (. ).      ,        ( , ,  , ,  )      - ,                 ,  .[37 -  .: Whitaker R. A Sovereign Idea. Essays on Canada as a Democratic Community. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1999.]    ,        ,   - .[38 -  :       ,       ,        XX   XXI               . , .   . ,     ,    . ,    XIV. ., .: Rethinking the Constitution. Perspectives on Canadian Constitutional Reform, Interpretation and Theory / ed. by A. Peacock. Oxford; N. Y.: Oxford Univ. Press, 1996. P. 224229.]

                                  - .   ,         (. . 2.1 . .),            -  (. ).          -    .           -,  .  (18351922),  ,  ,       ,     .[39 -  1926.   .]        ,   ,             ,      .[40 - Dicey A. Op. cit. P. XCV, XCIX, CVII, 8586, 395.   ,            20    500,          15 ,      .          -  ,     (Ibid. P. 396).     ,             (Ibid.).         .]  ,         - ,[41 -    .  . . 1.     / . . . . . .: , 1987. . 48.]       -   ,          .[42 - ., .: Sproule-Jones M. The Enduring Colony. Political Institutions and Social Sciences in Canada // Publius. A Journal of Federalism. 1984. Vol. 14. No. 1. P. 9097.]

                                     .               ,  ,      .              (. , . , . , . ),        .[43 - ., .: Careless J. Canada. A Political and Social History. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1959; Creighton D. Canadas First Century. Toronto: Macmillan, 1978; Lower A. A History of Canada. Toronto; Montreal: Longman Publishers, 1957.]          ,        (1931.).[44 -  ,            ,  -     ( . . 2.2 . .).]       ,  ,    XX .     19401950- .        ,  .   . .     . , . . , . .            -     .

   -       .  (18991985)         (-) .       .[45 -  .   .: Drummond I. Francis Richard Scott // The Canadian Encyclopedia / ed. by L. Marsh. Vol. 3. Edmonton: Hurtig, 1990. P. 16631664; Djwa S. The Politics of Imagination. A Life of F. R. Scott. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1997.]       .      (1977.).           94     .                     ()      ( . . 2.1 . .),    1940-  ,       . ,   ,      .[46 - Scott F. Essays on Constitution P. 124125; . : Canadian Federalism. Past, Present, Future / ed. by M. Burgess. L.; Leicester: Leicester Univ. Press, 1990. P. 44; Power Divided. The Theory and Practice of Contempory Federalism / ed. by J. Coffee. Berkley (Cal.): Univ. Press of America, 1995. P. 319, 322.]   XX .        ,                               .[47 -             .]

.         .[48 - Scott F. Op. cit. P. 109, 164.   .         - .  (Rousseau Ch. Droit international publique. P.: Larousse, 1953).]  ,             ,              .            , ..  ,           .    ,     .[49 - Scott F. Op. cit. . 315.]           .  ,  ,       ,      ,      .  .                ,       ,   ,      .               .[50 - Ibid. P. 288.]        -.[51 - Smiley D. The Federal Condition in Canada. Toronto: McGraw-Hill  Ryerson, 1990. P. 149; Vaughan F. The Critics of Judicial Committee of Privy Council. New Orthodoxy and Alternative Explanation // Canadian Journal of Political Science. 1996. Vol. 29. No. 1. P. 495519.]

                          .[52 - .: Hogg P. Op.cit. P. 190.]     ,     1980-     ,          ,        1960- ,        ,     -     1949.        ,           -     .           ,      -.  .      ,       XX .,              ,        -   ,      .

  .          .  (19041992)     ,  -              [53 - Forsey E. Freedom and Order. Collected Essays. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1984. P. 120124.      .     .         .]   .          ,     ,            .   ,       .                        XX . ,   ,    .

            -         () ,       .[54 - Canadian Federalism. Past, Present, Future P. 228; Stevenson G. Unfulfilled Union. Canadian Federalism and National Unty. 3d ed. Toronto: Gage, 2004. P. 1617.]

       ,  .     .        .         ,          -       (1215.),    (1628).,    (1689.),    (1701.).         .[55 - The Canadian Encyclopedia. Vol. 1. P. 406; Hogg P. Op. cit. P. 67; Tardif A. The Legal Framework of Government. The Canadian Guide. Toronto: Canada Law Books, 1995. P. 20.]

         .    .  (19211990)  - . .  (19192000).    ( 1960- ) ,   ,   ,          .      ()          -                     ,           .[56 - Smiley D. Op. cit. P. 102.]                   .               ,       ,        .    ,     ,         - . ,   ,          ,                   .[57 - Smiley D. Op. cit. P. 265266.]

.      ,  -  (    )        .[58 -  . . 3.2 . .]

                         - .              ໠           ,      .[59 - Smiley D. Op. cit. P. 58, 93, 143.            .:  . .   ,     //   . 2002. 8. . 1219;  .       //   . 2002. 7. . 1823.]

. .     ,              ( -   -),[60 -  .: The Canadian Encyclopedia. Vol. 3. P. 17291730.] ,          ,   -       XX .   ,   -             -           ,     ,          ,           .          ,        .        ,          ( . . 2.1 . .).       . .    :        ,     .[61 - Vadeboncour P. To Be or Not to Be. Montreal: Editions Hexagone, 1990. P. 27. .: Trudeau P. Conversations with Canadians. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1973. P. 71, 108.]     ,   , ,     .

   . .   ,              .[62 -  .:  . .   .    . .: , 1981.] ,   ,    ,      ,  ,   ,     ,      ,            .      ,  . ,      ,    .[63 - Future of Canadian Federalism / ed. by P. Crepeau, C. Macherson. Toronto: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1965. P. 34. . : Rethinking the Constitution; Young R. The Secession of Quebec and Future of Canada. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1998.        .         .             ,     -  (., .: Laforest G. Pierre Trudean and the End of Canadian Dream. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1996. P. 115, 144).   , ,  ,             ,          . , . , . -, .   . .]

  .   .  . .         ,         -     .[64 -       (New Trends in Canadian Federalism / ed. by M. Oliver, R. Whitaker. Philadelphia: Temple Univ. Press, 2002. P. 16, 23).           ,         .   1963.]       (  )     . ,    ,   ,  ,    .       -    ()                  ,   -     .[65 - Trudeau P. Federalism and French Canadians. N. Y.; L.: Macmillan, 1977. P. 157159. . :  . . . . . 8688, 128143.]      () .

    :             ,      ,  ,         ,           (. ).[66 - Mallory J. The Structure of Canadian Government. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1990. P. 231.]  ,  . . ,             .    .[67 - Trudeau P. Federalism and French Canadians P. 203.]

  () ,     , , ,    ,     ,     .            -       .[68 - Whitaker R. A Sovereign Idea P. 211, 294.] ,       .    ,                         ,     ,   ,       .[69 - Russell P. et al. Federalism and the Charter. Leading Constitutional Pecisions. Ottawa: Carleton Univ. Press, 1990. P. 407.]  - ,              .[70 -     ,     .  (Smiley D. Op. cit. P. 159).]           .

              ,     -        (. . . , . , .   , . , .    ).[71 - Brown B. The New Confederation. Five Sovereign Provinces. Victoria (B.C.): Hancock House, 1997; Chaput M. Why I am a Separatist. Montreal: Editions Quebec Amerique, 1963; Vallieres P. Behind October Scenario. Assasination of Pierre Laporte. Toronto: James Lorimer, 1977; Idem. The Impossible Quebec. The Illusions of Sovereignty  Association. Montreal: Black Rose Books, 1980. P. 18, 23, 38; Johnson W. A Canadian Myth. Province of Quebec Between Canada and Illusion of Utopia. Toronto: James Lorimer, 1994. P. 4254.]    XX          . ,           ,        .        .     - . , .   . .[72 -  .: Bouchard L. Un nouveau parti pour tape dcisive. Quebec City: Fides,1993; Levesque R. My Quebec. Agincourt (Ont.): Methuen-Carswell, 1984; Remillard G. The Reform of Federal Institutions. Quebec City: Les presses de universite Laval, 1985; Vadeboncour P. Op. cit.]

              .       XX ,             (.   . .).          . , ,      ,   ,            ,     . ,      ,     -       ( . . 2.2  . 3.4 . .).        , , , ,              .               39  52    .[73 - Comparative Constitutional Federalism: Europe and America / ed. by M. Tushnet. L.: Eyre and Spottiswood, 1990. P. 210212, 259; Jovell J. et al. The Changing Constitution. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press, 2000. P. 216, 355.]

  -          ,  .         ,             ,[74 - ., .: Arbess D., Trebilcock M. Limitations of Legislative Override under Canadian Charter of Rights. A Matter of Balancing Legal Values // Osgoode Hall Law Journal. 1993. Vol. 31. No. 1. P. 115141; Blais A., Nadeau R. To Be or Not to Be Sovereign. Quebeckers Perennial Dilemma // Canadian Public Policy. 1992. Vol. 18. No. 2. P. 89103; Cairns A. The Past and Future of Canadian Administrative State // University of Toronto Law Journal. 1990. Vol. 40. No. 4. P. 249271; Dean J. W. An Approach to Regulation of Banking Institutions in Federal States // National Journal of Constitutional Law. 1999. Vol. 40. No. 1. P. 311; Greene I. Are Language Rights Fundamental? // Osgoode Hall Law Journal. 1987. Vol. 28. No. 4. P. 639669; Healey T. Federalism and Treaty Power // Columbia Law Review. 1998. Vol. 59. No. 7. P. 17591786; Keppel-Jones A., Thorburn H. Why Not a Two-Nations Canada? // Policy Options. 1992. Vol. 9. No. 2. P. 115; Morton F. How Not to Amend Constitution // Canadian Parliamentary Review. 1993. Vol. 12. No. 3. P. 102114.]   ,          ,       -.[75 - Christiano K. Federalism as Canadian National Ideal: Civic Rationalism of Pierre Elliott Trudeau // Dalhousie Law Review. 1989. Vol. 89. No. 1. P. 248269; ΒConnell R. Guardians of Constitution. Unconstitutional Constitutional Norms // Journal of Civil Liberties. 1999. Vol. 48. No. 4. P. 5071; Ross C. Recrafting Federalism in Canada and Russia. Powers, Budget and Governance // Canadian Slavonic Papers. 2006. Vol. 48. No. 1. P. 415421.]

               ,   -               .   ,  . , . , .    .,[76 -  .:    XIX. .: , 1983;  . .     XVIIIXIX. .: , 1988.]             .        ,     ( )      ,    ,       .

,        -   .   .      .                ,[77 - Stevenson G. Op. cit. P. 107.]          ,      (-    -).[78 -      , -,          1950- .         (Evolving Canadian Federalism / ed. by A. Lower. Durham (N.C.): Duke Univ. Press, 1958).   ,   ,     ,     ,              (.: Barnett H. Op. cit.; Bradley M., Ewing K. Op. cit; Phillips O. H. Op. cit. .).            ,          ,            ,         .        ,   ,     ,     ,   -,       . .]    ,                  ,     . , . -, . , . , . , . , . , . .[79 - Cairns A. Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms versus Federalism. The Dilemmas of Constitutional Reforms. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1992; Fournier P. Meech Lake Post-Mortem. Is Quebec Sovereignty Inevitable? Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1992; Hodgins B. Where Economy and Constitution Meet in Canada. Montreal: C. D. Howe Institute, 1981; Mallory J. Op. cit.; McRoberts K. et al. Beyond Quebec. Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1993; Morton F. Charter Politics. Scarborough (Ont.): Nelson, 1995; Stevenson G. Unfulfilled Union. Canadian Federalism and National Unity. Toronto: Gage, 2004; Whitaker R. Op. cit.]

 ,     ,     (. , . , . , . , .  , . , . , . , . , . , . , . , . , . , .   .)          ,                 .

 ,     ,        .   . , . , . , . , . , . , .                 -    ,  , ,           .  , , . ,    ,     .     ,            .        . .[80 - ., .: Stevenson G. Op. cit.; Idem. Canadian Federalism and Quebec Sovereignty. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 2003; Williams D. et al. The Disruptions. The Constitutional Struggle from the Charter of Rights and Freedoms to Meech Lake. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1993.]      (. -, . , . , . , . , . , .   .),       .   . .          - ,           .         ,  ,    -   ,       ,              .

   ,   -           ,  :       ;      ;       ,     ;       ,  .

             ,  ,   ,     .  ,       ,             ,             ,      ..[81 -  .:  . .  . .:  , 2007. . 1, 3.]               ,         ,    ,     ..    - ,          .[82 - ., .: Knopff R. The Legal Theory and Patriation Debate // Queens Law Journal. 1981. Vol. 17. No. 1. P. 4167; Macdonald R. Meech Lake Towards Contrary Notwithstanding // Osgoode Hall Law Journal. 1991. Vol. 29. No. 3. P. 402417; Morton F. L., Russell P. The Supreme Court of Canada. First One Hundred of Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms Decisions. A Statistical Analysis // Osgoode Hall Law Journal. 1994. Vol. 36. No. 3. P. 386408; Smith J. Canadian Federation and Influence of American Federalism // Canadian Journal of Political Science. 1993. Vol. 26. No. 1. P. 115154; Valcke C. Quebec Civil Law and Canadian Federalism // Yale Journal of International Law. Winter 1996. Vol. 21. No. 1. P. 67120; Young R. The Political Economy of Secession. The Case of Quebec // Constitutional Political Economy. 1994. Vol. 5. No. 2. P. 221245.]

               (. , . ),       (. , . , . , . ),       , ,      (. , . . ).[83 - Comparative Constitutional Federalism. Europe and America P. 358.]                  -.

,            .   ,                 .                    .        ,       .[84 - Trudeau P. Federalism and French Canadians P. 203.]         ,     , ,                     ,[85 - Trudeau P. Approaches to Politics. Toronto: Summerhill Press, 1971. P. 215.      .    -    . , .   . ,  . , . , .        .  (c 2006.).]  ,  ,   . . .   ,              .[86 - Laforest G. Op. cit. P. 201.]         .

  ,                  ,          -.   ,     ,     .

                  -,               .     , ,      - .          .           19902000-       -          -  ,        ,            .[87 - Tierney M. Constitutional Law and National Pluralism. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press, 2005.]




 2

        





2.1

             


        XIX .[88 - ,                 .     1645. .: Constitutional Predicament. Canada after the Referendum of 1992 / ed. by C. Cook. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1994. P. 161.]          ,         .          .       [89 -            .       -      ( )    ( ).]




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/s-u-danilov/evoluciya-kanadskogo-federalizma/?lfrom=236201804&ffile=1)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


.   :    . .: , 1986;    80- .   . .: , 1979;   . .: , 1972;    . .: , 1986. .  :  . .   . .: - , 1985;  . .,  . . 12  . .: , 1987; - . .  . .: - , 1985;  . .,  . .  . .: , 1982;  . .     . .: , 1975.




2


 . .         . : -  . . -, 2003;  .  :    . .; : -  . . -, 2004;  . .   .     . .: - , 2002.




3


       .




4


      . ., .:  . .     . .: , 1998. . 1114; : , ,  (- ) / . . . . . .: , 2001. . 1133;  :  . .:  , 1997; Bradley J., Ewing M. Constitutional and Administrative Law. L., Harlow: Pearson Press, 2003. P. 153156; Durand C. Confdration de tats et tat federal. P.: Flammarion, 1995. P. 79. . : Hogg P. The Constitutional Law of Canada. Agincourt (Ont.): Carswell, 2007. P. 7274; Smiley D. The Federal Condition in Canada. Toronto: McGraw-Hill  Ryerson, 1991. P. 47.




5


      1999.




6


 .: Federalism. The Multiethnic Challenge / ed. by G. Smith. L.; N. Y.: Longman, 1999. P. 2431; Phillips O. H. Constitutional and Administrative Law. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2008. P. 255.




7


Barnett J. Constitutional and Administrative Law. L.: Macmillan, 2003. P. 187, 190, 201; Laselva S. The Moral Foundations of Canadian Federalism. Paradoxes, Achievments and Tragedies of the Nationhood. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1996. P. 193194.




8


       : Friedrich C. Theory and Practice of Federalism. N. Y.: Praeger, 1968; King P. Federalism and Federations. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press, 1982.




9


 .: Heard A. The Canadian Constitutional Conventions. Marriage of Law and Politics. Oxford; N. Y.: Oxford Univ. Press, 1991. . 3940; Marshall G. The Constitutional Conventions. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1986. . 79, 16; Oliver M. The Passionate Debates. Confederation or Federation? Montreal: Vehicule Press, 2001. P. 228239.




10


Whitaker R. Federalism and Democratic Theory. Essays in Principles and Their Implementation. 2nd ed. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 2000. P. 2531.




11


.: Federalist Papers. Essays by Hamilton A., Madison J. and Jay J. /ed. by J. Brock. L.: Dent Publishers, 1997. P. 7274, 234236.




12


 .:    XVIIXVIII. .: , 1983.




13


 . .  . .: , 1955. . 268269. . : Banks M.-F. Understanding Canadian Constitution. L. (Ont.): Univ. of Western Ontario Press, 1991. . 1116; Reconciling the Solitudes. Essays on Canadian Federalism and Nationalism / ed. by G. Laforest, M. Trebilcock. Montreal; L.: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 2003. P. 457458.




14


The Federalist Papers P. 110157  .




15


 . .    . .:  , 2000; The Federalist Papers




16


 . . . . . 312, 315; Nation-State versus Continental Integration / ed. by L. Pal, R. Schultze. Bochum: Universitatsverlag, 1993. P. 176; Verney D. Three Civilizations, Two Cultures, One State. Canadian Political Traditions. Durham (N.C.): Duke Univ. Press, 1996. P. 372, 373.




17


    .: : , ,  . 5; Boothe P. et al. Alberta and Constitutional Change. Edmonton: Western Centre for Research, 1992; Durand C. Op. cit.




18


., .:  . . . .:  -, 2004. . 291308.




19


.: Martin G. et al. The Causes of the Confederation. Fredericton (N.B.): Acadian Press, 1990. . , 46. ,                       ,           ,    -  .  ,                         .




20


    -  (,  .   .   ,   , .   .   )              .  ,  :         (sic!) ,      ,       .  :         ( .  .   . .: - . . -, 2005. . 154, 171).  ,               (. ).




21


Calhoun J. A Discourse on the Constitution and Government. N. Y.: Lippincott Publishing House,1849. P. 118, 146. . : The Canadian and American Constitutions in Comparative Perspective / ed. by M. McKenna, R. Gibbins. Calgary: Univ. of Calgary Press, 1999. P. 72; Dufour C.  Canadian Challenge. Halifax: Institute for Research on Public Policy, 1990. P. 4041; Forbes H. et al. Atlantic Provinces in Confederation. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1994. . 129.




22


Borel . tude sur la souverainete et lEtat federatif. P.: Flammarion, 1886. P. 103.




23


., .: Broadway R. The Folly of Decentralization in Canadian Federation. Calgary: Detselig Publishers, 1996. P. 124127, 132.




24


.:  .-. . .: , 1998.




25


 . . . . 184.    ,      ,     ,                      (, )   .




26


Dicey A. An Introduction to the Study of the Constitution. 10th ed. Indianapolis: Liberty Classics, 1982. P. 8586; . : Scott F. Essays on Constitution. Aspects of Canadian Law and Politics. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1987. P. 60.




27


        - (. . 1.2 . .).




28


Wheare K. The Federal Government. L.: Routlege and Keegan, 1964. P. 33.




29


,        (1983.)     .  .     (. 1, 1987.)      .




30


Acton J. Essays on Freedom and Power. Cleveland; Evanston: Univ. Press of America, 1962. P. 158159.




31


Ibid. P. 170.       .




32


Federalism and Nationalism / ed. by M. Forsyth. L.; Leicester: Leicester Univ. Press, 1989. P. 118; Laselva S. Op. cit. P. 89.




33


., .: Storing G. The Complete Anti-Federalist. Chicago: Walsh Company, 1981. P. 60, 113.




34


 .   . .: , 1929. . 545548, 567.




35


.: Giguel G. Le droit constitutionnel et institutions administrative. P.: Larousse, 2007; Ormsby W. The Emergence of a Federal Concept in Canada. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1969.




36


., .:  . .    (   ). .: , 2006. . 5253.




37


 .: Whitaker R. A Sovereign Idea. Essays on Canada as a Democratic Community. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1999.




38


 :       ,       ,        XX   XXI               . , .   . ,     ,    . ,    XIV. ., .: Rethinking the Constitution. Perspectives on Canadian Constitutional Reform, Interpretation and Theory / ed. by A. Peacock. Oxford; N. Y.: Oxford Univ. Press, 1996. P. 224229.




39


 1926.   .




40


Dicey A. Op. cit. P. XCV, XCIX, CVII, 8586, 395.   ,            20    500,          15 ,      .          -  ,     (Ibid. P. 396).     ,             (Ibid.).         .




41


   .  . . 1.     / . . . . . .: , 1987. . 48.




42


., .: Sproule-Jones M. The Enduring Colony. Political Institutions and Social Sciences in Canada // Publius. A Journal of Federalism. 1984. Vol. 14. No. 1. P. 9097.




43


., .: Careless J. Canada. A Political and Social History. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1959; Creighton D. Canadas First Century. Toronto: Macmillan, 1978; Lower A. A History of Canada. Toronto; Montreal: Longman Publishers, 1957.




44


 ,            ,  -     ( . . 2.2 . .).




45


 .   .: Drummond I. Francis Richard Scott // The Canadian Encyclopedia / ed. by L. Marsh. Vol. 3. Edmonton: Hurtig, 1990. P. 16631664; Djwa S. The Politics of Imagination. A Life of F. R. Scott. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1997.




46


Scott F. Essays on Constitution P. 124125; . : Canadian Federalism. Past, Present, Future / ed. by M. Burgess. L.; Leicester: Leicester Univ. Press, 1990. P. 44; Power Divided. The Theory and Practice of Contempory Federalism / ed. by J. Coffee. Berkley (Cal.): Univ. Press of America, 1995. P. 319, 322.




47


            .




48


Scott F. Op. cit. P. 109, 164.   .         - .  (Rousseau Ch. Droit international publique. P.: Larousse, 1953).




49


Scott F. Op. cit. . 315.




50


Ibid. P. 288.




51


Smiley D. The Federal Condition in Canada. Toronto: McGraw-Hill  Ryerson, 1990. P. 149; Vaughan F. The Critics of Judicial Committee of Privy Council. New Orthodoxy and Alternative Explanation // Canadian Journal of Political Science. 1996. Vol. 29. No. 1. P. 495519.




52


.: Hogg P. Op.cit. P. 190.




53


Forsey E. Freedom and Order. Collected Essays. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1984. P. 120124.      .     .         .




54


Canadian Federalism. Past, Present, Future P. 228; Stevenson G. Unfulfilled Union. Canadian Federalism and National Unty. 3d ed. Toronto: Gage, 2004. P. 1617.




55


The Canadian Encyclopedia. Vol. 1. P. 406; Hogg P. Op. cit. P. 67; Tardif A. The Legal Framework of Government. The Canadian Guide. Toronto: Canada Law Books, 1995. P. 20.




56


Smiley D. Op. cit. P. 102.




57


Smiley D. Op. cit. P. 265266.




58


 . . 3.2 . .




59


Smiley D. Op. cit. P. 58, 93, 143.            .:  . .   ,     //   . 2002. 8. . 1219;  .       //   . 2002. 7. . 1823.




60


 .: The Canadian Encyclopedia. Vol. 3. P. 17291730.




61


Vadeboncour P. To Be or Not to Be. Montreal: Editions Hexagone, 1990. P. 27. .: Trudeau P. Conversations with Canadians. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1973. P. 71, 108.




62


 .:  . .   .    . .: , 1981.




63


Future of Canadian Federalism / ed. by P. Crepeau, C. Macherson. Toronto: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1965. P. 34. . : Rethinking the Constitution; Young R. The Secession of Quebec and Future of Canada. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1998.        .         .             ,     -  (., .: Laforest G. Pierre Trudean and the End of Canadian Dream. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1996. P. 115, 144).   , ,  ,             ,          . , . , . -, .   . .




64


      (New Trends in Canadian Federalism / ed. by M. Oliver, R. Whitaker. Philadelphia: Temple Univ. Press, 2002. P. 16, 23).           ,         .   1963.




65


Trudeau P. Federalism and French Canadians. N. Y.; L.: Macmillan, 1977. P. 157159. . :  . . . . . 8688, 128143.




66


Mallory J. The Structure of Canadian Government. Toronto; Buffalo: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1990. P. 231.




67


Trudeau P. Federalism and French Canadians P. 203.




68


Whitaker R. A Sovereign Idea P. 211, 294.




69


Russell P. et al. Federalism and the Charter. Leading Constitutional Pecisions. Ottawa: Carleton Univ. Press, 1990. P. 407.




70


    ,     .  (Smiley D. Op. cit. P. 159).




71


Brown B. The New Confederation. Five Sovereign Provinces. Victoria (B.C.): Hancock House, 1997; Chaput M. Why I am a Separatist. Montreal: Editions Quebec Amerique, 1963; Vallieres P. Behind October Scenario. Assasination of Pierre Laporte. Toronto: James Lorimer, 1977; Idem. The Impossible Quebec. The Illusions of Sovereignty  Association. Montreal: Black Rose Books, 1980. P. 18, 23, 38; Johnson W. A Canadian Myth. Province of Quebec Between Canada and Illusion of Utopia. Toronto: James Lorimer, 1994. P. 4254.




72


 .: Bouchard L. Un nouveau parti pour tape dcisive. Quebec City: Fides,1993; Levesque R. My Quebec. Agincourt (Ont.): Methuen-Carswell, 1984; Remillard G. The Reform of Federal Institutions. Quebec City: Les presses de universite Laval, 1985; Vadeboncour P. Op. cit.




73


Comparative Constitutional Federalism: Europe and America / ed. by M. Tushnet. L.: Eyre and Spottiswood, 1990. P. 210212, 259; Jovell J. et al. The Changing Constitution. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press, 2000. P. 216, 355.




74


., .: Arbess D., Trebilcock M. Limitations of Legislative Override under Canadian Charter of Rights. A Matter of Balancing Legal Values // Osgoode Hall Law Journal. 1993. Vol. 31. No. 1. P. 115141; Blais A., Nadeau R. To Be or Not to Be Sovereign. Quebeckers Perennial Dilemma // Canadian Public Policy. 1992. Vol. 18. No. 2. P. 89103; Cairns A. The Past and Future of Canadian Administrative State // University of Toronto Law Journal. 1990. Vol. 40. No. 4. P. 249271; Dean J. W. An Approach to Regulation of Banking Institutions in Federal States // National Journal of Constitutional Law. 1999. Vol. 40. No. 1. P. 311; Greene I. Are Language Rights Fundamental? // Osgoode Hall Law Journal. 1987. Vol. 28. No. 4. P. 639669; Healey T. Federalism and Treaty Power // Columbia Law Review. 1998. Vol. 59. No. 7. P. 17591786; Keppel-Jones A., Thorburn H. Why Not a Two-Nations Canada? // Policy Options. 1992. Vol. 9. No. 2. P. 115; Morton F. How Not to Amend Constitution // Canadian Parliamentary Review. 1993. Vol. 12. No. 3. P. 102114.




75


Christiano K. Federalism as Canadian National Ideal: Civic Rationalism of Pierre Elliott Trudeau // Dalhousie Law Review. 1989. Vol. 89. No. 1. P. 248269; ΒConnell R. Guardians of Constitution. Unconstitutional Constitutional Norms // Journal of Civil Liberties. 1999. Vol. 48. No. 4. P. 5071; Ross C. Recrafting Federalism in Canada and Russia. Powers, Budget and Governance // Canadian Slavonic Papers. 2006. Vol. 48. No. 1. P. 415421.




76


 .:    XIX. .: , 1983;  . .     XVIIIXIX. .: , 1988.




77


Stevenson G. Op. cit. P. 107.




78


     , -,          1950- .         (Evolving Canadian Federalism / ed. by A. Lower. Durham (N.C.): Duke Univ. Press, 1958).   ,   ,     ,     ,              (.: Barnett H. Op. cit.; Bradley M., Ewing K. Op. cit; Phillips O. H. Op. cit. .).            ,          ,            ,         .        ,   ,     ,     ,   -,       . .




79


Cairns A. Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms versus Federalism. The Dilemmas of Constitutional Reforms. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1992; Fournier P. Meech Lake Post-Mortem. Is Quebec Sovereignty Inevitable? Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1992; Hodgins B. Where Economy and Constitution Meet in Canada. Montreal: C. D. Howe Institute, 1981; Mallory J. Op. cit.; McRoberts K. et al. Beyond Quebec. Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1993; Morton F. Charter Politics. Scarborough (Ont.): Nelson, 1995; Stevenson G. Unfulfilled Union. Canadian Federalism and National Unity. Toronto: Gage, 2004; Whitaker R. Op. cit.




80


., .: Stevenson G. Op. cit.; Idem. Canadian Federalism and Quebec Sovereignty. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 2003; Williams D. et al. The Disruptions. The Constitutional Struggle from the Charter of Rights and Freedoms to Meech Lake. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1993.




81


 .:  . .  . .:  , 2007. . 1, 3.




82


., .: Knopff R. The Legal Theory and Patriation Debate // Queens Law Journal. 1981. Vol. 17. No. 1. P. 4167; Macdonald R. Meech Lake Towards Contrary Notwithstanding // Osgoode Hall Law Journal. 1991. Vol. 29. No. 3. P. 402417; Morton F. L., Russell P. The Supreme Court of Canada. First One Hundred of Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms Decisions. A Statistical Analysis // Osgoode Hall Law Journal. 1994. Vol. 36. No. 3. P. 386408; Smith J. Canadian Federation and Influence of American Federalism // Canadian Journal of Political Science. 1993. Vol. 26. No. 1. P. 115154; Valcke C. Quebec Civil Law and Canadian Federalism // Yale Journal of International Law. Winter 1996. Vol. 21. No. 1. P. 67120; Young R. The Political Economy of Secession. The Case of Quebec // Constitutional Political Economy. 1994. Vol. 5. No. 2. P. 221245.




83


Comparative Constitutional Federalism. Europe and America P. 358.




84


Trudeau P. Federalism and French Canadians P. 203.




85


Trudeau P. Approaches to Politics. Toronto: Summerhill Press, 1971. P. 215.      .    -    . , .   . ,  . , . , .        .  (c 2006.).




86


Laforest G. Op. cit. P. 201.




87


Tierney M. Constitutional Law and National Pluralism. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press, 2005.




88


,                 .     1645. .: Constitutional Predicament. Canada after the Referendum of 1992 / ed. by C. Cook. Montreal; Kingston: McGill-Queens Univ. Press, 1994. P. 161.




89


           .       -      ( )    ( ).


